Shop our Black Magic Collection | Spend $35 and receive our Eyeko Eye Mask | Exclusive GWP Bundle when you spend $40

Black Magic Mascara

Customer Reviews

Black Magic Mascara

Black Magic Mascara Customer Reviews

USD 26.0

$26.00

Overall Rating : 4.7 / 5 (37 Reviews)

37 Reviews

  • 32 5 star reviews
  • 2 4 star reviews
  • 1 3 star reviews
  • 1 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews

Quantity

Item limited to a max quantity of  5000

( 0 item in your basket items in your basket )

Overall Rating : 4.7 / 5 (37 Reviews)

37 Reviews

  • 32 5 star reviews
  • 2 4 star reviews
  • 1 3 star reviews
  • 1 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

Favorite mascara

5

I love this mascara, particularly the midnight blue color that has been discontinued. I hope Eyeko brings that back. The black is nice too. It's easy to apply, take off, and curls nicely. I hope Eyeko continues maintains the quality of its mascaras and not outsource production to China like it's been doing with its other products.

Report this review

Black Magic Mascara

5

Love it!! My favorite Nascar! Wish they still made the Black Magic Eyelash Booster too.. My eyelashes never looked better

Report this review

Curl + Length

5

Love this mascara. Have been looking for something that curls my long straight lashes and these make them look even longer and the curl lasts all night. Not difficult to remove either, so definitely a fan. 

Report this review

Not waterproof!

3

This mascara looks great, but I got caught in a rainstorm while wearing it. I NEVER use mascara that’s not waterproof, as I think women who cry or get wet with mascara on look pitiful. Guess what? I looked pitiful. Looks great dry, looks terrible if real life happens.

Report this review

Love it!

5

I always had problems with mascara , causing black under my eyes. i have been using this for 5 years. Lasts long time no clumping.

Report this review

Will never use anything else

5

Ive used this mascara for years now. Most mascaras give me raccoon eyes within 20 minutes but not this one! Makes my lashes look amazing for hours. I’ve tried so many mascaras  and this one is by far the best!

Report this review

Not for me

1

I should've read more reviews on this product because the description wasn't clear enough in warning that this is a "tube" mascara. I've tried tube mascaras in the past and have hated them all for various reasons. I've used this a couple times and have, unfortunately, already thrown it in the trash. It's unworkable and looks awful on my lashes. I know many factors go into whether we hate or love our mascaras, and it's all dependent on the type of lashes we have. The formula is important. The brush is important. All have to have the components that work for what we want to achieve. I have very decent lashes. They are long. They are full. They have a decent amount of curve to them naturally. At least for me, Black Magic is hard to apply (and I'm very adept at applying mascara and have done so for decades). You must work on the quicker side, or the formula "sets" and makes it hard to apply a 2nd coat if that's what you want, or to even comb through. I like to take my time applying mascara because you can really achieve a great look if you take your time, but this formula negates that approach. It also wears clumpy on me, even removing excess product from the brush. Two things I do like: I like the curved brush, as it's good at getting corners, and it is very black. But the tube formula itself is the pits for me. I wish it had worked out. I have a sample tube of Lash Alert that I hope works out better.

Report this review

Great Mascara

5

I bought three top rated mascaras around the same time as I was tiring of my regular one for various reasons, this was my favorite of the three... (others were MAC and younique)

Report this review

Natural

5

Goes on smoothly, no clumps although I sometimes like to use the end of the brush to get a thicker fuller look. This by far is one of my favorite go to mascaras. 

Report this review

Not Impressed

2

Goes on well, looks great but 2 hours after application, it started to smear and melt. I had hoped for better staying power. Will not purchase again.

Report this review