Shop our Black Magic Collection | Spend $35 and receive our Eyeko Eye Mask | Exclusive GWP Bundle when you spend $40

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

Customer Reviews

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner Customer Reviews

USD 22.0

$22.00

Overall Rating : 4.43 / 5 (14 Reviews)

14 Reviews

  • 11 5 star reviews
  • 1 4 star reviews
  • 0 3 star reviews
  • 1 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews

Quantity

Item limited to a max quantity of  5000

( 0 item in your basket items in your basket )

Overall Rating : 4.43 / 5 (14 Reviews)

14 Reviews

  • 11 5 star reviews
  • 1 4 star reviews
  • 0 3 star reviews
  • 1 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

Love it

5

I love this eyeliner it goes on so nice and smooth. Makes very nice sharp lines. 

Report this review

Trash Panda

5

I have struggled with eyeliner, for practically forever. I can do a mean wing with an angled brush and gel liners, but hate how smudgy they get almost immediately. Almost all other brands of eyeliner pens I have struggled with application or the durability of the product once on. This pen really is the best of them, in my option. The tip is stiff without being tough and has a formula of just the right consistency and flow to get precise lines even with my shaky hands and twitchy eyelids. The formula stays all day without a smudge but also removes easily with my generic eye makeup remover solution with no scrubbing. I have sensitive skin and often react to cheaper products especially on the eyes. This causes no irritation at all for me. I will buy this again and again. 

Report this review

Formula doesn't meet expectations

2

I'd heard so much hype about this eyeliner, but when it arrived, I found that it bled and feathered upon application so much that it's nearly impossible to wear. It needs multiple coats to achieve anything close to an opaque line, and the final application always looks messy. The quality of the applicator seems to be high, but I wouldn't recommend this formula. 

Report this review

Love it,but

5

I love this eyeliner and will always continue to buy it,my one complaint is that i didn't get the free travel liner despite it being added in my cart when i purchased.

Report this review

Great until it leaked out all over me

1

I loved this eyeliner until I took it on a trip with me. When I reached my destination I used this eyeliner to touch up my makeup in the bathroom and it leaked out all over my face and my shirt. It took me 10 minutes to get it all off my face, I had to redo my makeup and change my clothes. I still haven't been able to get the stain out of my shirt. I loved this product but would never purchase it again and risk this kind of disaster again.

Report this review

Love this stuff!

5

Originally got it in an Ipsy bag a few months ago - and now I'm addicted to it. Super dark, precise lines, and it stays all day. The only liquid liner I use anymore.

Report this review

Awesomely

5

I love this eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and stays on all day. It’s the only eye liner I will use. 

Report this review

Easy to apply, great staying power

4

The brush applicator is amazing, the eyeliner itself is a little bit thin, but looks really great overall. One of my favorite liquid liners

Report this review

Love it

5

Ooh I love it and it was stay long than other liquid eyeliner.

Report this review

Best eyeliner ever

5

By far my favorite eyeliner. Goes on smooth. It really does improve the length and thickness of my own lashes after about 5 days of use. Stays on pretty well, definitely not water proof by any means, but is a small downside compared to the overall product. Thank you eyeko!

Report this review